CABILLY & CO. BLOG

Inspiration or Infringement? When Copying Product Descriptions or Bullet Points Crosses the Line

As an Amazon seller, whether you’re just starting or have years of experience, understanding copyright laws is crucial to protecting your store from legal complications.

One area that often confuses sellers is the legality of using ideas from or copying parts of product descriptions, titles or bullet points from competitors’ listings. Is it a smart business strategy or a legal misstep?

In this article, we’ll explore this common question. Our goal is to shed light on this complex issue, helping you discern what is permissible and what could potentially lead to legal issues.

What copyrights means in the e-commerce space and what is protected

Before we dive into product descriptions or bullet points, it’s essential to have a clear understanding of what copyrights means in the e-commerce space and what is protected:

Photographs and Visuals: The images or graphic designs you create for your product listings are protected by copyrights, as artistic works. For instance, if you have a designed butterfly on the paper plates you sell- these would be copyrighted. The main image of your product would also be protected .

Creative Product Descriptions: The way you describe your product, including the bullet points, product descriptions, your website content, A+ content, packaging content etc., are all protected by copyrights

Understanding these elements is crucial because it helps you appreciate the importance of creating original content for your e-commerce store. It’s not just about avoiding legal pitfalls; it’s about respecting the creative efforts of others just as you would want yours to be respected.

Copy or Copyright? Text Usage Limits for Amazon Sellers

A common question among Amazon sellers and content creators is “What is the extent of text copying that would be considered a copyright violation? Is copying one sentence acceptable? Or perhaps two or three sentences? What about an entire paragraph?” The answer to this question isn’t straightforward and hinges on the concept of originality and context rather than a specific word count:

No Definitive Number: Copyright law doesn’t specify a fixed number of sentences or words that can be safely copied without infringement. It’s not about the quantity, but the quality- originality and context of the content.
Generic vs. Unique Sentences: A generic sentence or two, unlikely to be seen as uniquely creative, might be safe. However, copying even a single sentence from a work that is highly distinctive or central to the original piece could be problematic.
Context Matters: If a sentence or section is a crucial part of the original work, copying it might be considered an infringement, regardless of its length. This is particularly true for texts with a high degree of creativity or uniqueness.

The Fine Line of Product Descriptions:
Creating an engaging and legally compliant product description can be challenging. The essential aspect to understand in this scenario is what constitutes copyright infringement. Copyright law protects original works of authorship, including literary works, and that’s precisely what your product descriptions are.

It’s imperative to be as strict as possible in this regard. Any form of copying text, even in small amounts, can be viewed as an infringement of intellectual property, leading to significant consequences. These repercussions can include the suspension of your listing and even more serious legal issues.

Therefore, it is vital to ensure that all elements of your product listing, including images bullet points and descriptions, are authentically produced by you. This not only keeps you on the right side of the law but also helps in carving out a distinct identity for your brand in the competitive e-commerce landscape. Originality in your product listings is not just a legal requirement; it’s a strategic advantage in today’s market.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid:

Direct Copying:

Example 1: Replicating another seller’s unique product description or bullet points, word-for-word. This is a clear violation of copyright laws.

For instance, copying the following sentence would constitute copyright infringement:

“THE LAST DRINK MIXER SET YOU’LL EVER NEED! A complete bartending kit cocktail set with all the bar cart essentials equipment you need to shake & mix up delicious adult alcoholic drinks & mocktails”

Example 2: Using specific phrases or slogans that are uniquely associated with another brand or product. Even if these are catchy or seem generic, they might be legally protected. For instance, “JUST DO IT”

It’s important to understand that even if the copied content seems minor, like a catchy tagline or a well-phrased feature description, it can still lead to legal issues.

Images and External Content:

Example 1: Using a competitor’s product images, or even modified similar versions of these images, without permission.
Example 2: Incorporating external media, such as videos, graphics, or detailed graphs from other sources, without verifying their copyright status or obtaining necessary permissions.

Visual elements are also protected under copyright law. Using someone else’s images or media can be as problematic as copying text.

The key to avoiding these pitfalls is a combination of creating original content, conducting thorough research, respecting legal boundaries, and when in doubt, consulting with legal experts.

How to Create Compliant Product Descriptions:

Originality is Key:

Example 1: Crafting a narrative around your product that reflects its unique story or the brand ethos, rather than sticking to generic or overused descriptions.
Example 2: Using creative and unique adjectives and phrases that differentiate your product from others.

Writing from scratch allows you to infuse your brand’s voice and personality into the descriptions, making them more engaging and distinctive.

Focus on Your Product’s Unique Features:

Example 1: Highlighting a special feature in your product that isn’t commonly found in similar items.
Example 2: Describing a unique use or benefit of your product that sets it apart from competitors.

Emphasizing what makes your product unique not only helps in standing out but also ensures that you’re not inadvertently copying elements from other descriptions.

Use Clear and Accurate Descriptions:

Providing precise specifications and details about the product that are factual and verifiable.
Accuracy in descriptions not only builds customer trust but also avoids legal issues related to misrepresentation or false advertising.

Consult Legal Experts if Unsure:

Seeking advice from IP lawyers for products in highly competitive or legally sensitive categories.

Legal counsel can help navigate the nuances of IP law, especially for products that might be in a gray area of copyright or trademark law.

By focusing on these aspects, you can create product descriptions and bullet points that are not only compliant with IP laws but also engaging and effective in differentiating your products in the Amazon marketplace. This approach not only protects your business legally but also enhances your brand’s reputation for quality and authenticity.

Can I Use and Publish Product Descriptions Created by a Brand or Manufacturer I Work With?

A common query among Amazon sellers is whether it’s acceptable to use product descriptions and texts directly from manufacturers. This is particularly relevant for those who resell products they purchase from other companies and brands.

Here’s what you need to know:

Manufacturer Permissions:

Often, manufacturers provide product descriptions that resellers are permitted to use. However, it’s essential to confirm this. Explicit permission from the manufacturer to use their descriptions can save you from unintentional copyright infringement.

These may be prior clients’ descriptions:

In some cases, manufacturers may provide permission to use their content, yet the text or photos may not originate from the manufacturer, but rather from a previous customer of the manufacturer. This could result in the unintentional violation of third-party copyrights.

Differentiation:

While using manufacturer-provided descriptions can be convenient, it might not always be the best strategy for standing out on Amazon. Remember, other resellers might be using the same descriptions, which could diminish your product’s uniqueness.

Customization:

To differentiate your product listings, consider customizing the manufacturer’s descriptions. Add your unique touch by highlighting specific features or benefits relevant to your target audience. This approach combines convenience and originality, setting your products apart in the competitive Amazon marketplace.

Therefore, while it’s always tempting to save time and use existing materials, the safest course of action would be to create your own content.

Final Thoughts

Navigating the fine line between inspiration and infringement on platforms like Amazon requires a nuanced understanding of intellectual property laws.

As an Amazon seller, your safest bet is to invest in creating original content for your product listings, from descriptions to bullet points. This approach not only safeguards you against legal complications but also provides a strategic advantage in a competitive marketplace.

While it may be tempting to use existing materials or draw heavily from competitors, doing so can lead to serious repercussions, including copyright infringement issues. To ensure compliance and protect your brand’s integrity, it is advisable to consult with IP counsel when in doubt, especially in complex or borderline cases. By prioritizing originality and legal diligence, you set the stage for a successful and sustainable e-commerce venture.

Legal Disclaimer: The articles published on our platform are for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice in any form. They are not intended to be a substitute for professional legal counsel. For any legal matters, it is essential to consult with us or a qualified attorney who can provide advice tailored to your specific situation. Reliance on any information provided in these articles is solely at your own risk.
Contact us

Table of Contents